236 CHAPTER 10. REGULAR MEASURES

If U is open and contains V, then µ (U)≥ µ (V ) and so

µ (V )≤ inf{µ (U) : U ⊇V, U open} ≤ µ (V ) since V ⊆V.

Thus µ is inner and outer regular on open sets. In what follows, K will be closed and Vwill be open.

Let K be the open sets. This is a π system since it is closed with respect to finiteintersections. Let

G ≡ {E ∈B (X) : µ is inner and outer regular on E} so G ⊇K .

For E ∈ G , let V ⊇ E ⊇ K such that µ (V \K) = µ (V \E)+µ (E \K)< ε . Thus KC ⊇ EC

and so µ(KC \EC

)= µ (E \K)< ε. Thus µ is outer regular on EC because

µ(KC)= µ

(EC)+µ

(KC \EC)< µ

(EC)+ ε, KC ⊇ EC

Also, EC ⊇ VC and µ(EC \VC

)= µ (V \E) < ε so µ is inner regular on EC and so G is

closed for complements. If the sets of G {Ei} are disjoint, let Ki⊆Ei⊆Vi with µ (Vi \Ki)<ε2−i. Then for E ≡ ∪iEi,and choosing m sufficiently large,

µ (E) = ∑i

µ (Ei)≤m

∑i=1

µ (Ei)+ ε ≤m

∑i=1

µ (Ki)+2ε = µ (∪mi=1Ki)+2ε

and so µ is inner regular on E ≡ ∪iEi. It remains to show that µ is outer regular on E.Letting V ≡ ∪iVi,

µ (V \E)≤ µ (∪i (Vi \Ei))≤∑i

ε2−i = ε.

Hence µ is outer regular on E since µ (V ) = µ (E)+µ (V \E)≤ µ (E)+ ε and V ⊇ E.By Dynkin’s lemma, G = σ (K )≡B (X).2.) Suppose that µ is outer regular on sets of F ⊇B (X). Letting E ∈F , by outer

regularity, there exists an open set V ⊇ EC such that µ (V )−µ(EC)< ε . Since µ is finite,

ε > µ (V )− µ(EC)= µ

(V \EC

)= µ

(E \VC

)= µ (E)− µ

(VC)

and VC is a closed setcontained in E. Therefore, if 8.17 holds, then so does 8.16. The converse is proved in thesame way. There is K ⊆ EC with ε > µ

(EC \K

)= µ

(KC \E

)showing outer regularity

from inner regularity.3.) The last claim is obtained by letting G = ∩nVn where Vn is open, contains E,

Vn ⊇Vn+1, and µ (Vn)< µ (E)+ 1n and Kn, increasing closed sets contained in E such that

µ (E) < µ (Kn)+1n . Then let F ≡ ∪Fn and G ≡ ∩nVn. Then F ⊆ E ⊆ G and µ (G\F) ≤

µ (Vn \Kn)< 2/n. ■Next is a lemma which allows the replacement of closed with compact in the definition

of inner regular.

Lemma 10.1.3 Let µ be a finite measure on a σ algebra containing B (X) , the Borelsets of X , a separable complete metric space, Polish space. Then if C is a closed set,

µ (C) = sup{µ (K) : K ⊆C and K is compact.}

It follows that for a finite measure on B (X) where X is a Polish space, µ is inner regularin the sense that for all F ∈B (X),µ (F) = sup{µ (K) : K ⊆ F and K is compact}

236 CHAPTER 10. REGULAR MEASURESIf U is open and contains V, then u (U) > uw (V) and soL(V) <inf{u(U):U DV, U open} < W(V) since V CV.Thus y is inner and outer regular on open sets. In what follows, K will be closed and Vwill be open.Let .% be the open sets. This is a 7 system since it is closed with respect to finiteintersections. LetG = {E € A(X) : pis inner and outer regular on E} soY D .%.For E €Y, letV DE 2K such that u(V\K) =u (V\E)+u(E\K) <e. Thus K© D E©and so pt (K© \ E©) = w(E\K) < €. Thus pl is outer regular on E© because(KS) =H (ES) + EU (KO\ES) <H(ES) +e, KO DESAlso, EC > V© and p (E©\ V°) = w(V\ E) < € so pis inner regular on E© and so & isclosed for complements. If the sets of Y {E;} are disjoint, let K; C E; C V; with pu (V; \ Ki) <€2~'. Then for FE = U;£;,and choosing m sufficiently large,~ LEE ys du (Ei) +e <and so p is inner regular on E = U;£;. It remains to show that u is outer regular on E.Letting V = UV,Ms(Ki) +2€ = (UM) Ki) +2€llmnIu(V\E) <p (U;(V;\ E;)) ser ‘aeHence yl is outer regular on E since u(V) =U (E)+uU(V\E) <u(E)+eandV DE.By Dynkin’s lemma, ¥ = 0 (.%) = B(X).2.) Suppose that uy is outer regular on sets of YF D A(X). Letting E € FY, by outerregularity, there exists an open set V D EC such that (V) — ut (E©) < €. Since p is finite,e€>pu(V)—pU(ES) =U (V\ES) =p (E\V°) =u (E) —uU (VS) and VC is a closed setcontained in E. Therefore, if 8.17 holds, then so does 8.16. The converse is proved in thesame way. There is K C E© with € > uw (E©\ K) = uw (K© \ E) showing outer regularityfrom inner regularity.3.) The last claim is obtained by letting G=M,V, where V, is open, contains E,Vi > Viti, and yt (V, n) <P(E)+ 1 and K,,, increasing closed sets contained in E such thatU(E) < (Kn) +4. Then let F = “UF, and G=M,Vy. Then F CE CGand u(G\F)<L(Vn \ Kn) <2/n. 'Next is a lemma which allows the replacement of closed with compact in the definitionof inner regular.Lemma 10.1.3 Let u be a finite measure on a o algebra containing &(X) , the Borelsets of X, a separable complete metric space, Polish space. Then if C is a closed set,EL (C) = sup {yu (K) : K CC and K is compact.}It follows that for a finite measure on &(X) where X is a Polish space, pL is inner regularin the sense that for all F € B(X),u(F) = sup {u(K) : K C F and K is compact}